Hmm. Yes, okay. Let's see.
Lost: See El Cid's post, really. There's been... a lot of crap on this show (much of Seasons 2 & 3 qualifies, here), but goddamnit if Season 1 wasn't basically pitch-perfect all the way through. I mean, really. Also, Season 4 has been damned solid so far and I'm really psyched to see how things play out when it comes back. Benjamin Linus for the fucking win.
Battlestar Galactica: Am I seriously the only one who watches this? How is that possible? Again, see the caveat I provided for Lost, but reduce the amount of crap by... a pretty large factor, and add somewhat better writing/acting (generally) and much better central storyline focus. Even though a clunker episode comes along here and there, I can basically forgive it all for the Season 2 finale and first four episodes of Season 3. That and all the other amazing stuff the show has done. Plus, it's intelligent sci-fi. Whoda thunk it? Colonel Tigh for the fucking win.
South Park: I've actually really liked this season so far. I don't mind at all when the show gets surreal and bizarre. Or even preachy, as long as it stays funny. I wouldn't consider myself a huge South Park fan (except for maybe Imaginationland), but it's still solid and worth watching. Butters for the fucking win.
Scrubs: Looking forward to the return, even though Season 7 has sucked pretty badly so far. The show really did hit a steep decline starting with Season 6, and they probably should have called it quits there. Oh well. Janitor for the fucking win.
Arrested Development: Haven't actually watched it recently, but yeah. It's hands-down the best comedy ever. Every single character for the fucking win.