51
Discussion / Re: Rate the characters 2: RATE HARDER!
« on: August 29, 2010, 05:57:33 PM »
Final Fantasy IV
Cecil: 5/10. Good start, but becomes dull once he turns into a paladin.
Rosa: 3/10. To much damsel in distress for my taste and not very interesting. I don't recall her doing anything idiotic though which keeps her out of my hate induced scores.
Kain: 4/10. Drives the story forward and his struggle was somewhat interesting. I do however wish they had figured out something else than him loving Rosa, that element did nothing but make him pathetic and kills any possible sympathy one may have for him. Had he say been just as capable as Cecil, but Cecil received more recognition for the same effort and that made him feel envious, it would have been easier to emphasize with his situation. However, by not respecting that Rosa choose another man he had absolutely nothing going for him.
Cid: 5/10. Kinda likable for the screentime he had.
Rydia: 7/10. A bit like Cecil in that she has a good start, but becomes just there once her arc is over. I found her more likable and fun though.
Tellah: 6/10. Dies during his arc meaning he escapes the "just there" problem. Also stays dead. One bonus point for his famous line.
Edward: 4/10. Despite all the tragedy surrounding him, I found it hard to care. Him dispelling the heightened gravity with the power of music is just dumb. Had he died after that act I may have cared more.
Yang: 3/10. He's there. Also, congratulations to FF IV for making a "save the party by self-sacrifice" scene have the same emotional impact as a "let's shop from the grocery" scene.
Palom: 6/10. Feels relevant for all the time he spends in the party and then exits before he sinks into the "just there" hole. Also manages to have the only self sacrifice scene that had any impact on me. To bad his revival was anticlimactic, but no big deal.
Porom: 6/10. See Palom.
Edge: 5/10. Kinda fun at times, kinda annoying at times.
FuSoYa: 4/10. Uninteresting.
Milon: Abstain. Barely qualifies as a character.
Cagnazzo: Abstain. Despite him impersonating the king he still comes of as just a boss fight and not as a character.
Valvalis: See Milon.
Rubicante: 5/10. A decent effort at making a boss a character as well. Noble villain, but that's it though.
Golbez: 5/10. Could have been much better had Zemus not existed. He worked as a credible threat and him turning into a hand after a defeat was kind of cool. Him being controlled by Zemus and then having that control simple dispelled by FuSoYa is a kick in the balls though.
Zemus/Zeromus: 1/10. Should not have existed. His reveal just made the plot worse. Also, his hatred being so strong killing him just makes him more angry is just plain stupid.
BONUS!!!! - Chip N' Dale: Rescue Rangers
Chip: 4/10. The most "normal" one of the cast. Levelheaded characters can be just as fun and interesting as the quirky ones, but this is not the case here.
Dale: 6/10. More fun than Chip, but I never found him <i>that</i> funny.
Monterey Jack: 4/10. Very plain except for his cheese gimmick which is just that, a gimmick.
Gadget: 8/10. I remember her being capable and not much of a damsel in distress. Also likable and her nerdness wasn't overplayed to the point of irritation.
Zipper: 6/10. Likable and manages to express himself well without having a voice.
Fat Cat: 5/10. Pretty standard as a cartoon villain. I don't recall him having any gimmick that irritated me though, so that's always that.
Professor Nimnul: 5/10. Stock crazy scientist. Not fun or stylish or anything like that, but does his job to create problems for the Rescue Rangers to solve.
Cecil: 5/10. Good start, but becomes dull once he turns into a paladin.
Rosa: 3/10. To much damsel in distress for my taste and not very interesting. I don't recall her doing anything idiotic though which keeps her out of my hate induced scores.
Kain: 4/10. Drives the story forward and his struggle was somewhat interesting. I do however wish they had figured out something else than him loving Rosa, that element did nothing but make him pathetic and kills any possible sympathy one may have for him. Had he say been just as capable as Cecil, but Cecil received more recognition for the same effort and that made him feel envious, it would have been easier to emphasize with his situation. However, by not respecting that Rosa choose another man he had absolutely nothing going for him.
Cid: 5/10. Kinda likable for the screentime he had.
Rydia: 7/10. A bit like Cecil in that she has a good start, but becomes just there once her arc is over. I found her more likable and fun though.
Tellah: 6/10. Dies during his arc meaning he escapes the "just there" problem. Also stays dead. One bonus point for his famous line.
Edward: 4/10. Despite all the tragedy surrounding him, I found it hard to care. Him dispelling the heightened gravity with the power of music is just dumb. Had he died after that act I may have cared more.
Yang: 3/10. He's there. Also, congratulations to FF IV for making a "save the party by self-sacrifice" scene have the same emotional impact as a "let's shop from the grocery" scene.
Palom: 6/10. Feels relevant for all the time he spends in the party and then exits before he sinks into the "just there" hole. Also manages to have the only self sacrifice scene that had any impact on me. To bad his revival was anticlimactic, but no big deal.
Porom: 6/10. See Palom.
Edge: 5/10. Kinda fun at times, kinda annoying at times.
FuSoYa: 4/10. Uninteresting.
Milon: Abstain. Barely qualifies as a character.
Cagnazzo: Abstain. Despite him impersonating the king he still comes of as just a boss fight and not as a character.
Valvalis: See Milon.
Rubicante: 5/10. A decent effort at making a boss a character as well. Noble villain, but that's it though.
Golbez: 5/10. Could have been much better had Zemus not existed. He worked as a credible threat and him turning into a hand after a defeat was kind of cool. Him being controlled by Zemus and then having that control simple dispelled by FuSoYa is a kick in the balls though.
Zemus/Zeromus: 1/10. Should not have existed. His reveal just made the plot worse. Also, his hatred being so strong killing him just makes him more angry is just plain stupid.
BONUS!!!! - Chip N' Dale: Rescue Rangers
Chip: 4/10. The most "normal" one of the cast. Levelheaded characters can be just as fun and interesting as the quirky ones, but this is not the case here.
Dale: 6/10. More fun than Chip, but I never found him <i>that</i> funny.
Monterey Jack: 4/10. Very plain except for his cheese gimmick which is just that, a gimmick.
Gadget: 8/10. I remember her being capable and not much of a damsel in distress. Also likable and her nerdness wasn't overplayed to the point of irritation.
Zipper: 6/10. Likable and manages to express himself well without having a voice.
Fat Cat: 5/10. Pretty standard as a cartoon villain. I don't recall him having any gimmick that irritated me though, so that's always that.
Professor Nimnul: 5/10. Stock crazy scientist. Not fun or stylish or anything like that, but does his job to create problems for the Rescue Rangers to solve.