RPG Ratings

[Tonfa]

Ranking lists for RPGs you've played go here. Preferably in a /10 format.

Links to latest invidual lists: (number listed is page)

Aktar 2
Chapin 2
Ciato 1
Clear Tranquil 5
CmdrKing 1
CompmanJX3 2
Dark Holy Elf 1
Dhyerwolf 1
DjinnandTonic 2
DomaDragoon 1
Drifloon 11
dude789 8
El Cideon 1
Gatewalker 2
Halbarad 7
Hunter Sopko 1
Idun 5
Jo'ou Ranbu 2
Lady Ashe 1
Linthar 1
Meeplelard 1
Monkeyfinger 5
Nitori 1
OblivionKnight 9
Orson 3
PurpleOutsider 8
Rob The Stampede 2
Scar 11
Shale 1
SnowFire 2
Strago 1
superaielman 1
Taishyr 1
Talaysen 1
Tide 5
Tonfa 1
Twilkitri 2
Yoshiken 8

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

My personal list goes here.

10/10
---
Soul Nomad & the World Eaters
Phantom Brave
The World Ends With You

9.5/10
---
Ys Origin
Star Ocean: Till the End of Time
Vagrant Story

9/10
---
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy X-2
Star Ocean: The Second Story
The Last Remnant
Live A Live

8.5/10
---
Breath of Fire 4
Final Fantasy V
Atelier Iris 3: Grand Phantasm
Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories

8/10
---
Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne
Ar Tonelico: Melody of Elemia
Wild Arms 4

7.5/10
---
Final Fantasy Tactics Advance 2: Grimoire of the Rift
Final Fantasy X
Final Fantasy VIII
Rudra no Hihou
Riviera: The Promised Land
Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII
Ys: Oath In Felghana
Final Fantasy XII

7/10
---
Parasite Eve 2
Dark Cloud 2
Atelier Annie: Alchemists of Sera Island
Digital Devil Saga
Final Fantasy Tactics
Disgaea: Hour of Darkness
Suikoden 2
Atelier Iris 2: The Azoth of Destiny
Jade Cocoon 2

6.5/10
---
Chrono Trigger
Valkyrie Profile
Makai Kingdom
Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones
Fire Emblem 7
Great Greed
Ranma 1/2 RPG: Treasure of the Red Cat Gang

6/10
---
Legend of Legaia
Atelier Iris: Eternal Mana
La Pucelle: Tactics
.hack//Mutation
.hack//Infection

5.5/10
---
.hack//Outbreak
Final Fantasy IX
Shadow Hearts
Ys Eternal
Kingdom Hearts

5/10
---
Wild ARMs
Suikoden
Breath of Fire 3
Pokemon R/B/Y*

4.5/10
---
Valkyrie Profile: Silmeria
Pokemon Mysterious Dungeon
Final Fantasy II
Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings

4/10
---
Final Fantasy VI
Bahamut Lagoon
Star Ocean

3.5/10
---
Breath of Fire 2
Onimusha Tactics*
Dragon Quest Monsters: Joker
Dragon View

3/10
---
Seiken Densetsu 3
Grandia
Jade Cocoon
Super Mario RPG
Golden Sun
Final Fantasy 3

2.5/10
---
.hack//Quarantine
Breath of Fire
Chrono Cross*
Final Fantasy IV

2/10
---
Unlimited Saga*
Final Fantasy Tactics Advance

1.5/10
---
Final Fantasy

1/10
---
Drakkhen
Tales of Phantasia
Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together*

0.5/10
---
Secret of the Stars
ADOM*
Lufia 1

0/10
---
Super Hydlide*
Hydlide*
Dragon Slayer*

[Shale]

Straight C+P from the old board:

10/10 [Perfect in every way I care about. Has flaws, but they don't impede my enjoyment of the game at all.]
Panzer Dragoon Saga
Final Fantasy VI [PS1, SNES]
Final Fantasy Tactics
Xenogears

9/10 [Excellent in most ways, but has flaws that actually matter, or is generally not quite as good as it could be.]
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete [PS1]
Chrono Trigger
Dragon Force
Phantasy Star IV
Deus Ex
Shadow Hearts: Covenant
Vagrant Story

8/10 [Really damn good, but could be improved in significant ways.]
Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII
Shining Force III Scenario 1
Final Fantasy X
Shining Force II
Grandia [PS1]
Super Robot Wars Original Generations
Super Robot Wars Original Generation Gaiden
Super Robot Wars Alpha 3: To The End of the Universe
Super Robot Wars Alpha Gaiden
Secret of Mana
Shadowrun [Genesis]
Alundra
Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria
Dragon Quest VIII
Shadow Hearts: From the New World
Parasite Eve
Tales of Phantasia (PS1)

7/10 [Generally a good game, but could use improvement in significant areas and isn't so excellent in others that they're balanced out.]
Final Fantasy V
Dragon Warrior VII
Breath of Fire IV
Romancing SaGa: Minstrel Song
Super Robot Taisen: Original Generation
Shadow Hearts
Kingdom Hearts
Grandia II [Dreamcast]
Skies of Arcadia [Dreamcast]
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy IX
Shining the Holy Ark
Super Mario RPG
Super Robot Wars W
Disgaea: Hour of Darkness
Vandal-Hearts
Vandal-Hearts II
Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones
Fire Emblem: The Blazing Sword
Front Mission 3
Front Mission 4
Wild ARMs 4
Super Robot Wars: Destiny
Super Robot Wars MX
Super Robot Taisen: Original Generation 2

6/10 [Pretty good but unexceptional. Also the home of objectively not-great games that I can still replay happily]
Breath of Fire III
Wild ARMs 2
Valkyrie Profile
Tales of Phantasia
Koudelka
Legaia 2: Dual Saga
Secret of Evermore
Shining Force
Dark Cloud 2
Fire Emblem: The Sealed Sword
Final Fantasy IV
Albert Odyssey: Legend of Eldean

5/10 [Enjoyable, once. Not good enough to bear a replay, with qualities worth playing for]
Lunar 2: Eternal Blue Complete [PS1]
Legend of Legaia
Record of Lodoss War [Dreamcast]
Lunar: The Silver Star [Sega CD]
Suikoden II
Final Fantasy II: Dawn of Souls
Star Ocean: The Second Story
Legend of Dragoon
Pokemon Fire Red
Mega Man Battle Network
Magic Knight Rayearth [Saturn]
Wild ARMs
Chrono Cross
Pokemon Sapphire
Jade Cocoon

4/10 [Flawed enough that a first playthrough takes work to stay with, or just games that have nothing particularly good about them at all.]
Tales of Destiny
Lunar: Legend [GBA]
Shenmue
Phantasy Star II
Suikoden
Xenosaga Episode I
Final Fantasy X-2
Live A Live
Mega Man Battle Network 2
Mega Man Battle Network 3
Arc the Lad
Wild Arms XF

3/10 [Has redeeming factors, but not enough to make the game worth playing.]
Final Fantasy VIII
Dragon View
Arc the Lad 2

2/10 [Just plain bad.]
Beyond the Beyond
Seiken Densetsu 3

1/10 [truly awful. Not fun in any way, and possibly causes physical pain.]
The Last Remnant

[Nitori]

10:

Earthbound
Final Fantasy VI
Mother 3
Super Mario RPG

9.5:

Final Fantasy Tactics

9:

Final Fantasy X
Persona 4
Pokemon (all)
Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor
The World Ends With You

8.5:

Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn
Shadow Hearts Covenant
Mana Khemia 2
Wild ARMs XF

8:

Fire Emblem 9
Paper Mario
Persona 3 FES: The Journey
Phantasy Star IV
Soulblazer
Tales of the Abyss
Wild ARMs 4

7.5:

Disgaea 2
Live a Live
Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga
Super Robot Taisen: Original Generation

7:

Digital Devil Saga 2
Dragon Quest V: Hand of the Heavenly Bride
Chrono Trigger
Crisis Core: Final Fantasy 7
Etrian Odyssey
Etrian Odyssey 2
Final Fantasy IV (SNES, GBA)
Final Fantasy V Advance
Grandia 2
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
Mana Khemia
Shadow Hearts
Super Robot Taisen OG Saga: Endless Frontier

6.5:

Ar tonelico 2: Melody of Metafalica
Digital Devil Saga
Dragon Quest 8
Dragon Warrior Monsters 2
Shin Megami Tensei: Persona
Skies of Arcadia Legends
Suikoden 2
Suikoden Tierkreis

6:

Ar tonelico: Melody of Elemia
Atelier Iris: Eternal Mana
Atelier Iris 2: Azoth of Destiny
Dragon Warrior Monsters
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy Legend II
Final Fantasy Tactics A2: Grimoire of the Rift
Fire Emblem 7
Fire Emblem 8
Legaia 2: Duel Saga
Megaman X Command Mission
Shadows Hearts From the New World
Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood
Star Ocean: First Departure
Suikoden
Summon Night: Swordcraft Story
Tales of Symphonia
Wild Arms 3
Xenosaga Episode II: Jenseits von Gut und Bose

5.5:

Disgaea
Dragon Quest 4 DS
Lufia 2
Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria

5:

Final Fantasy (PSX)
Final Fantasy VIII
Jeanne d'Arc
Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time
Odin Sphere
Shining Force 2
Suikoden 4
Summon Night: Swordcraft Story 2
Xenosaga Episode I: Der Wille Zur Macht

4.5:

Wild ARMs 5

4:

Arc the Lad 2
Breath of Fire II (GBA)
Final Fantasy 3 DS
Final Fantasy XII
Fire Emblem 4: Genealogy of the Holy War
Luminous Arc
Shining Force
Tales of Destiny
Tales of Phantasia

3.5:

Breath of Fire
Wild Arms: Alter Code F
Xenosaga Episode III: Also sprach Zarathustra

3:

Lufia & the Fortress of Doom
Ranma 1/2: Treasure of the Red Cat Gang

2:

Arc the Lad
Final Fantasy Tactics Advance
Golden Sun
Phantasy Star 2

1:

0:

Dragon Warrior (GBC)
Phantasy Star

[DomaDragoon]

Also C+P'd from old board, with a few additions.

So I figured I played enough new games for an update to my list. I'm sure there's still some games I've played that I'm forgetting about, as well as some I own that I'll get to eventually (Suiko V, SO3, WA V, that Inuyasha RPG). Hey, Met, what's the asterisk for beside my name? Don't tell me Mark Ecko got to you, too.

Now with Alphabetical Power!

10/10:
Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin (added)
Disgaea
Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories
Fallout 2
Final Fantasy Tactics
Nethack
PokÈmon Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald

9/10:
Baldur's Gate 2
Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow (added)
Final Fantasy IV Advance
Final Fantasy V
La Pucelle
Planescape: Torment
PokÈmon FR/LG
PokÈmon Gold/Silver
PokÈmon RBY
Shining Force: Resurrection of the Dark Dragon
Shining Force II
Wild ARMs 4

8/10:
Breath of Fire IV
Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
Chrono Trigger
Dragon Warrior IV
Fallout
Final Fantasy IV
Final Fantasy VI
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy X
Final Fantasy X-2
Live a Live
Lunar 2
Shadowrun - SNES
Shining Force
Suikoden II
Suikoden III
Valkyrie Profile
Valkyrie Profile - Silmeria
Wild ARMs: Alter Code F
Wild ARMs 3

7/10:
Breath of Fire III
Castlevania: Circle of the Moon
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night
Diablo II
Earthbound
Final Fantasy: Dawn of Souls
Final Fantasy Tactics Advance
Grandia 2
Kingdom Hearts
KOTOR
Legaia 2: Duel Saga
Legend of Legaia
Lunar Legends
Lunar SSSC
Megaman X: Command Mission
Odin Sphere
Phantasy Star IV
Phantasy Star II
Skies of Arcadia
Star Ocean II
Suikoden
Suikoden 4
Super Mario RPG
Wild ARMs 2

6/10:
Arc the Lad
Arc the Lad 2
Baldur's Gate
Breath of Fire
Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter
Diablo
Dragon Warrior V
Dragon Warrior VII
Final Fantasy VIII
Final Fantasy IX
Final Fantasy Legend II
Final Fantasy Mystic Quest
Grandia
Kingdom Hearts 2
Lufia 2
Makai Kingdom
Mario and Luigi: Superstar Saga
Paper Mario
Phantom Brave
Sailor Moon: Another Story
Shadowrun - Genesis
Shadow Hearts
Tactics Ogre: The Knight of Lodis
Tales of Destiny
Tales of Eternia
Tales of Phantasia
Vandal Hearts
Wild ARMs 1

5/10:
Arc the Lad 3
Chrono Cross
Dragon Quest VI
Dragon Warrior III
Dungeons and Dragons: Heroes
Final Fantasy Legend
Final Fantasy Legend III
Golden Sun 2
Great Greed
Legend of Dragoon
Lufia
Mega Man Battle Network
Parasite Eve
Pokemon Rescue Team Red
SaGa Frontier
Seiken Densetsu 3
Sword of Mana
Tenchi Muyo RPG
Ultima: Quest of the Avatar
Xenogears
Zelda 2: Adventure of Link

4/10:
Arcana
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance - GBA version
Crystalis
Dragon Ball Z: Legend of the Super Saiyajin
Dragon Warrior
Dragon Warrior II
Dragon Warrior Monsters
Final Fantasy
Final Fantasy Anthology
Final Fantasy Chronicles
Golden Sun
Legend of Mana
Morrowind
Ranma 1/2 RPG
Secret of Evermore
Seiken Densetsu / Final Fantasy Adventure
Terranigma

3/10:
Final Fantasy III
Illusion of Gaia
Phantasy Star
Phantasy Star III
SaGa Frontier 2
Secret of Mana
Shining Soul
Threads of Fate
Ultima: Runes of Virtue
Vagrant Story
Xenosaga Ep. 1

2/10:
Breath of Fire II
Castlevania: Harmony of Dissonance
Monstania
Soul Blazer
Sweet Home

1/10:
Dragon Ball Z: The Legacy of Goku
Drakkhen
Dungeons and Dragons: Heroes of the Lance
Hydlide
J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings Volume 1 - SNES
Kingdom Hearts: Chain of Memories
Lagoon
Shining and the Darkness
The 7th Saga

[El Cideon]

Must get my list on the first page for ease of use (my ease of use, of course. What else matters?) Total games ranked: 96

An asterisk denotes an unfinished game.

~

10 (Personal Favorites)

Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter
Odin Sphere
Planescape: Torment
Star Ocean: 'Til the End of Time


9 (Excellent games, some of which probably deserve tens objectively, but I'm just not as fond of them as those above)

Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn
Fallout 2
Final Fantasy Tactics
Final Fantasy X
Soul Nomad & the World Eaters


8 (Very good)

Dragon Age: Origins
Persona 4
Phantasy Star IV
Shadow Hearts: Covenant
Suikoden III
Suikoden V
Tales of the Abyss
Vagrant Story
Valkyria Chronicles
Valkyrie Profile
Wild Arms 3


7 (Good, fun games. Not revolutionary perhaps, but definitely above average in my estimation)

Anachronox
Chrono Trigger
Final Fantasy VI
Final Fantasy VII
Front Mission 4
Growlanser 2
Lunar: Eternal Blue Complete
Mana Khemia: Alchemists of Al-Revis
Persona 2: Eternal Punishment
Skies of Arcadia: Legends
Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria
Wild Arms 4


6 (Decent games, or otherwise good ones with notable flaws)

Atelier Iris: Eternal Mana
Atelier Iris 2: The Azoth of Destiny
Disgaea: Hour of Darkness
Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories
Disgaea 3: Absence of Justice
Fallout
Grandia 2
Grim Grimoire (DNR)
Growlanser 3
Growlanser: Heritage of War
La Pucelle: Tactics
Lufia 2: Rise of the Sinstrals
Mega Man X: Command Mission
Ogre Battle: March of the Black Queen
Parasite Eve
Saga Frontier
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga 2  
Star Ocean: The Second Story
Suikoden 2
Wild Arms 5
Wild Arms: XF
Xenogears
Xenosaga
Xenosaga II
Xenosaga III


5 (Average)

Dragon Warrior IV
Final Fantasy IV
Final Fantasy VIII
Koudelka
Legaia 2: Duel Saga
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
Persona 3
Shadow Hearts
Shining Force
Shining Force 2
Wild Arms 2
Wild Arms: Alter Code F


4 (We are now descending into mediocrity)

.hack//Infection
.hack//Mutation
Ar Tonelico
Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy
Final Fantasy IX*
Final Fantasy XII
Mana Khemia 2: Fall of Alchemy
Phantasy Star
Phantasy Star II
Phantasy Star III
Shadow Hearts: From the New World
Suikoden
Suikoden IV


3 (Just bad in general, with a few small saving graces)

Breath of Fire
Eternal Sonata
Final Fantasy V
Phantasy Star Universe
Stella Deus: The Gate of Eternity


2 (Awful, with perhaps a few brief glimmers of amusement)

Legend of Dragoon
Dragon Warrior
Unlimited SaGa*


1 (Truly wretched and without any redeeming value)

Breath of Fire 2
Ultima: Quest of the Avatar (NES)


0 (Actively painful to play)

Final Fantasy II*
Ultima: Exodus (NES)*

[Talaysen]

*== unfinished

10/10
Cross Edge [PS3]
Final Fantasy X [PS2]
Mana Khemia: Alchemists of Al-Revis [PS2]
Rhapsody: A Musical Adventure [PS]
Rhapsody: A Musical Adventure [DS]
Super Robot Taisen Original Generations [PS2]
Wild ARMs 4 [PS2]

9/10
.hack//G.U. Volume 1: Rebirth [PS2]
.hack//G.U. Volume 2: Redemption [PS2]
.hack//G.U. Volume 3: Reminisce [PS2]
Ar tonelico: Melody of Elemia [PS2]
Ar tonelico II: Melody of Metafalica [PS2]
Atelier Iris 2: The Azoth of Destiny [PS2]
Breath of Fire IV [PS]
Breath of Fire V: Dragon Quarter [PS2]
Disgaea 3: Absense of Justice [PS3]
Etrian Odyssey II: Heroes of Lagaard [DS]
Final Fantasy Tactics [PS]
Final Fantasy Tactics: The War of the Lions [PSP]
Final Fantasy VI [SNES/PS]
Final Fantasy VI Advance [GBA]
Final Fantasy XIII [PS3]
Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn [WII]
Growlanser: Heritage of War [PS2]
Legaia 2: Duel Saga [PS2]
Mana Khemia 2: Fall of Alchemy [PS2]
Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga [GBA]
Mega Man X: Command Mission [GC]
Persona 4 [PS2]
Phantom Brave [PS2]
Pokémon Diamond [DS]
Shadow Hearts Covenant [PS2]
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga [PS2]
Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne [PS2]
Star Ocean: The Second Story [PS]
Super Mario RPG [SNES]
Super Robot Taisen: Original Generation [GBA]
Super Robot Taisen: Original Generation 2 [GBA]
Tales of Vesperia [360]
Vagrant Story [PS]
Valkyrie Profile [PS]
Wild ARMs 3 [PS2]
Wild ARMs 5 [PS2]
Wild ARMs XF [PSP]
Xenogears [PS]
Xenosaga Episode I: Der Wille zur Macht [PS2]

8/10
.hack//Infection Part 1 [PS2]
.hack//Mutation Part 2 [PS2]
Arc the Lad 2 [PS]
Atelier Annie: Alchemists of Sera Island [DS]
Atelier Iris 3: Grand Phantasm [PS2]
Chrono Trigger [SNES/PS]
Demon's Souls [PS3]
Diablo II [PC]
Diablo II: Lord of Destruction [PC]
Ephemeral Fantasia [PS2]
Etrian Odyssey [DS]
Final Fantasy Adventure (Seiken Densetsu) [GB]
Final Fantasy Legend III (SaGa 3) [GB]
Front Mission 3 [PS]
Grandia III [PS2]
Kingdom Hearts 2 [PS2]
Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals [SNES]
Lunar 2: Eternal Blue Complete [PS]
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete [PS]
Mario & Luigi 2: Partners in Time [DS]
NieR [PS3]
Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door [GC]
Pokémon Blue [GB]
Pokémon Emerald [GBA]
Pokémon Red [GB]
Romancing SaGa: Minstrel Song [PS2]
Shadow Hearts: From the New World [PS2]
Suikoden V [PS2]
Super Robot Taisen Original Generation Gaiden [PS2]
Tales of the Abyss [PS2]
The Bard's Tale [PS2]
Wild Arms [PS]
Wild Arms Alter Code: F [PS2]
Xenosaga Episode II: Jenseits von Gut und Bose [PS2]

7/10
.hack//Outbreak Part 3 [PS2]
Atelier Iris: Eternal Mana [PS2]
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance [PS2]
Brave Story: New Traveler [PSP]
Castlevania II: Simon's Quest* [NES] DNR
Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories [PS2]
Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King [PS2]
Dragon Quest Monsters: Joker [DS]
Final Fantasy III DS [DS]
Final Fantasy IX [PS]
Final Fantasy Mystic Quest [SNES]
Gauntlet Legends [N64]
Glory of Heracles [DS]
Grandia [PS]
Kingdom Hearts [PS2]
Koudelka [PS]
Legend of Legaia [PS]
Ogre Battle [SNES/PS]
Paper Mario [N64]
Persona 2: Eternal Punishment [PS]
Planescape: Torment* [PC]
Pokémon Crystal [GB]
Pokémon Gold [GB]
Pokémon Yellow [GB]
SaGa Frontier [PS]
Shadow Hearts [PS2]
Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor [DS]
Soul Nomad & the World Eaters [PS2]
Suikoden III [PS2]
Suikoden Tierkreis [DS]
Tales of Eternia [PS]
The World Ends With You [DS]
Valkyrie Profile: Covenant of the Plume [DS]
World of Warcraft [PC]
Yggdra Union [GBA]
Zelda II: The Adventure of Link [NES]

6/10
.hack//Quarantine Part 4 [PS2]
Brain Lord [SNES]
Brave Fencer Musashi [PS]
Breath of Fire III [PS]
Chrono Cross [PS]
Disgaea: Hour of Darkness [PS2]
Dragon Quest IV: Chapters of the Chosen* [DS]
Eternal Poison [PS2]
Final Fantasy I: Dawn of Souls [GBA]
Final Fantasy Legend II (SaGa 2) [GB]
Final Fantasy V [PS]
Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance [GC]
Legend of Dragoon [PS]
Legend of Mana [PS]
Luminous Arc [DS]
Parasite Eve [PS]
Phantasy Star 4 [Gen]
Pokémon Stadium [N64]
Quest 64 [N64]
Sailor Moon: Another Story [SNES]
Sands of Destruction [DS]
Secret of Mana (Seiken Densetsu 2) [SNES]
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga 2 [PS2]
Star Ocean: Til the End of Time [PS2]
Suikoden Tactics [PS2]
Super Robot Taisen R [GBA]
Sword of Mana [GBA]
Tales of Destiny* [PS]
Trinity Universe [PS3]
Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria [PS2]
Vandal Hearts II [PS]
Vanguard Bandits* [PS]
Wild ARMs 2 [PS]
Wizardry: Tale of the Forsaken Land* [PS2]

5/10
7th Saga* [SNES]
Brigandine* [PS]
Diablo [PC]
Dragon Warrior Monsters 2: Cobi's Journey [GBC]
Final Fantasy [PS]
Final Fantasy VII [PS]
Final Fantasy VIII [PS]
Grandia II [PS2]
Jade Cocoon* [PS]
La Pucelle: Tactics [PS2]
Last Rebellion [PS3]
Magical Starsign [DS]
Saiyuki: Journey West* [PS]
Secret of Evermore* [SNES]
Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner - Raidou Kuzunoha vs. the Soulless Army [PS2]
Suikoden II [PS]
Suikoden IV [PS2]
Super Robot Wars Alpha* [PS]
The Legend of Zelda [NES] DNR
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker [GC] DNR
Vandal Hearts [PS]

4/10
Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirits [PS2]
Azure Dreams* [PS]
Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean [GC]
Dissidia: Final Fantasy [PSP]
Dragon Warrior V* [SNES]
Dragon Warrior Monsters [GBC]
Earthbound* [SNES]
Final Fantasy III [NES]
Final Fantasy IV [SNES/PS]
Final Fantasy Tactics Advance* [GBA]
Front Mission 4* [PS2]
Jade Cocoon 2* [PS2]
Kartia [PS]
Rondo of Swords* [DS]
Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3 [PS2]
Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3 FES [PS2]
Skies of Arcadia Legends [GC]
Suikoden [PS]
Tactics Ogre [PS]
Tales of Symphonia [GC]
Tales of the World: Narikiri Dungeon 3 [GBA]
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time* [N64] DNR
White Knight Chronicles [PS3]

3/10
Arc the Lad [PS]
Dragon Warrior IV [NES]
Eternal Eyes [PS]
Final Fantasy II (Origins) [PS]
Final Fantasy X-2* [PS2]
Final Fantasy XI [PC/PS2]
Final Fantasy XII [PS2]
Fire Emblem VII: The Blazing Sword [GBA]
Fire Emblem VIII: The Sacred Stones [GBA]
Granstream Saga [PS] DNR
Growlanser II: The Sense of Justice [PS2]
Guardian's Crusade* [PS]
Hoshigami: Ruining Blue Earth* [PS]
Lufia & the Fortress of Doom [SNES]
Radiata Stories* [PS2]
Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves [NES]
Secret of the Stars [SNES]
Star Ocean [SNES]
Star Ocean 4: The Last Hope [360]
Tactics Ogre: Knights of Lodis [GBA]
Tales of Legendia [PS2]
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past* [SNES] DNR
Thousand Arms [PS]
Xenosaga Episode III: Also Sprach Zarathustra [PS2]

2/10
Alundra 2* [PS] DNR
Alundra* [PS] DNR
Arc the Lad 3 [PS]
Breath of Fire [SNES]
Final Fantasy Legend (SaGa) [GB]
Growlanser III [PS2]
Izuna: Legend of the Unemployed Ninja [DS]
Lunar Legend [GBA]
Odin Sphere* [PS2]
Persona [PS]
SaGa Frontier 2* [PS]

1/10
Breath of Fire II [SNES]
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night [PS] DNR
DOOM: The Roguelike* [PC]
Dragon Warrior [NES]
Dragon Warrior III [NES]
Drakkhen* [SNES]
Final Fantasy IV Advance [GBA]
Lufia: The Ruins of Lore [GBA]
Mazes of Fate [GBA]
Mazes of Fate DS* [DS]
Rogue Galaxy* [PS2]
Sword of Hope [GB]
Ultima: Exodus [NES]

0/10
ADOM* [PC]
Dragon Slayer* [GB]
Dragon Warrior II [NES]
Grandia Xtreme [PS2]
Magna Carta* [PS2]
Phantasy Star [SMS/GBA]
Seiken Densetsu 3* [SNES]

[Cmdr_King]

General notes:
*= unfinished
I added system to everything, just because.

10/10- Excellent
Xenogears [PS1]
Final Fantasy VII [PS1]
Kingdom Hearts [PS2]
Suikoden III [PS2]
Shadow Hearts: Covenant [PS2]

9/10- Great
Kingdom Hearts: 358/2 Days [DS]
Kingdom Hearts II [PS2]
Final Fantasy X [PS2]
Chrono Cross [PS1]
Final Fantasy Tactics [PS1] (War of the Lions) [PSP]
Vagrant Story [PS1]
Chrono Trigger [PS1] [DS]
Grandia II [PS2]
Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door [GCN]
Suikoden V [PS2]
Suikoden II [PS1]
Tales of Vesperia [360]
Tales of the Abyss [PS2]
Valkyrie Profile [PS1]
Valkyrie Profile: Covenant of the Plume [DS]
Mana Khemia: Alchemists of Al Revis [PS2]
Soul Nomad & The World Eaters [PS2]
Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria [PS2]
Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter [PS2]

8/10- Good
Final Fantasy VIII [PS1]
Shadow Hearts [PS2]
Skies of Arcadia Legends [GCN]
Wild ARMs: Alter Code F [PS2]
Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII [PSP]
Persona 4 [PS2]
Star Ocean: First Departure [PSP]
Super Robot Taisen: Original Generation 2 [GBA]
Wild ARMs 2 [PS1]
Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn [Wii]
Wild ARMs XF [PSP]
Persona 2: Eternal Punishment [PS1]
Suikoden [PS1]
Super Mario RPG* [SNES]
Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance [GCN]
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night [PS1](Note: DNR)
Koudelka [PS1]
Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories [PS2]
Disgaea: Hour of Darkness [PS2]
La Pucelle: Tactics [PS2]
Lunar: Eternal Blue Complete [PS1]
Super Robot Taisen: Original Generation [GBA]
Pokémon Emerald [GBA]
Pokémon Platinum [DS]


7/10- Solid
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic [Xbox]
Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow [GBA] (DNR)
Wild ARMs 5 [PS2]
The Wizard of Oz: Beyond the Yellow Brick Road [DS]
Wild ARMs 4 [PS2]
Pokémon Heart Gold/Soul Silver [DS]
The World Ends With You [DS]
Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones [GBA]
Shadow Hearts: From the New World [PS2]
Tales of Symphonia [GCN]
Wild ARMs [PS1]
Dragon Quest V: Hand of the Heavenly Bride [DS]
Fire Emblem (7) [GBA]
Fire Emblem: Sword of Seals [GBA]
Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon [DS]
Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness [GCN]
Atelier Iris 2: The Azoth of Destiny [PS2]
Kingdom Hearts: Chain of Memories [GBA]
Final Fantasy IX [PS1]
Final Fantasy X-2 [PS2]
Final Fantasy Tactics Advance* [GBA]
Lunar Legend (SSSC) [GBA]
Suikoden IV [PS2]
Parasite Eve [PS1]
Legend of Dragoon [PS1]
Breath of Fire III [PS1]
Pokémon FR/LG [GBA]
Atelier Annie: Alchemists of Sera Island [DS]
Star Ocean: Till the End of Time [PS2]
Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirits [PS2]
Mega Man X: Command Mission [PS2]
Breath of Fire [GBA]
Dragon Quest IV: Chapters of the Chosen [DS]
Threads of Fate [PS1]
Pokémon Pearl/Diamond [DS]
Wild ARMs 3 [PS2]
Fullmetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel [PS2]
Grandia III [PS2]
Phantom Brave [PS2]
Disgaea 3: Absence of Justice [PS3]
Tales of Phantasia [GBA]
Tales of Legendia [PS2]
Persona 3: The Journey [PS2]
Xenosaga: Der Wille Zur Macht (Episode 1) [PS2]
Xenosaga: Jenseits von Gut und Bose (Episode 2)[PS2]
Xenosaga: Also Sprach Zarathustra (Episode 3)[PS2]
Suikoden Tactics [PS2]
Suikoden Tierkreis [DS]

6/10- Decent
Final Fantasy III [DS]
Castlevania: Circle of the Moon [GBA] (DNR)
Phantasy Star IV [GEN]
Dragon Quest VIII [PS2]
Rhapsody: A Musical Adventure [PS1]
Dragon Warrior IV [NES]
Pokémon Ru/Sa [GBA]
Radiata Stories [PS2]
Lufia II: Rise of the Sinstrals [SNES]
Riviera: The Promised Land [GBA]
Legaia 2: Duel Saga* [PS2]
Pokemon R/B/Y [GBC]
Pokémon Colosseum [GCN]
SaGa Frontier [PS1]
Tales of Eternia [PS1]

5/10- Average
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga (1) [PS2]
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga 2 [PS2]
Breath of Fire IV [PS1]
Final Fantasy IV [PS1]
Brigandine* [PS1]
Final Fantasy (DoS) [GBA]
Final Fantasy II (DoS) [GBA]
Star Ocean: The Second Story [PS1]
Grandia [PS1]
Final Fantasy V [PS1]
Brave Fencer Musashi [PS1]
Golden Sun [GBA]
Final Fantasy VI [PS1]

4/10- Mediocre
Pokemon G/S [GBC]
Inuyasha: Secret of the Cursed Mask* [PS2]

3/10- Crappy, but playable
Breath of Fire II [GBA]

2/10- Just plain crappy
Unlimited SaGa* [PS2]

1/10- Unplayable
Drakkhen [SNES]*

0/10- Utter Shit
Empty Set

[Taitoro]

Data Transfer initiated.... Data Transfer complete.

All ratings are out of 10, from 0 to 10.

MC NOTE: If this has any duplicates in the list, please take the lower of the two. On general principle, you see.

The three tiers of awesome. Anything within here is cool indeed.

9.8: Persona 2: Eternal Punishment [PSX]
9.6: Final Fantasy Tactics [PSX]
9.4: Breath Of Fire: Dragon Quarter [PS2]
9.2: The World Ends With You [DS]
9.1: Etrian Odyssey 2: Heroes of Lagaard [DS]

8.9: Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne [PS2]
8.8: Phantom Brave [PS2]
8.7: Final Fantasy V [SNES, GBA]
8.5: Legend Of Mana [PSX]
8.4: Shin Megami Tensei: Strange Journey [DS]
8.4: Labyrinth of Touhou [PC]
8.2: Super Robot Taisen: Original Generation 2 (SRT:OG2) [GBA]
8.1: Suikoden V [PS2]

7.9: Wild Arms 4 [PS2]
7.9: Persona 4 [PS2]
7.7: Front Mission 3 [PSX]
7.6: Final Fantasy Tactics A2: Grimoire Of The Rift [DS]
7.5: Breath of Fire 4 [PSX]
7.4: Monster Rancher 2 [PSX]
7.3: Borderlands [X360]
7.3: Dragon Warrior III [GBC]
7.3: Dragon Warrior Monsters 2 [GBC]
7.2: Mordor 1.1: The Depths of Dejenol [PC]
7.1: Shadow Hearts: Covenant [PS2]
7.1: Valkyrie Profile [PSX]
7.1: Suikoden III [PS2]
7.0: SaGa Frontier [PSX]

Anything below here is generally solid, with some weaknesses, good strengths, and usually fun. (Sometimes it's just explodeable.)

6.9: Disgaea: Hour of Darkness [PS2]
6.9: *Persona 3: The Journey (FES) [PS2]
6.8: Makai Kingdom [PS2]
6.7: *Meeple Fantasy VI [SNES EDIT]
6.7: Suikoden Tactics [PS2]
6.6: Super Robot Taisen: Original Generation 1 [GBA]
6.6: *Arcanum [PC]
6.6: *Wild Arms XF [PSP]
6.5: Final Fantasy X [PS2]
6.5: Ogre Battle [PSX, SNES]
6.5: Fire Emblem 8 [GBA]
6.4: Lunar 2: EBC [PSX]
6.4: Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor [DS]
6.4: Legaia 2: Duel Saga [PS2]
6.3: Digital Devil Saga 2 [PS2]
6.2: Dragon Quest VIII [PS2]
6.1: Wild Arms: ACF [PS2]
6.1: Star Ocean: Second Evolution [PSP]
6.0: Torchlight [PC]
6.0: Phantasy Star IV [GEN]

5.9: Azure Dreams [PSX]
5.9: Angband [PC]
5.8: *Wild ARMs 2 [PSX]
5.8: Secret Of Evermore [SNES]
5.8: *Etrian Odyssey [DS]
5.8: Nethack [PC]
5.7: Monster Rancher 1 [PS1]'
5.6: Lunar: SSSC [PSX]
5.6: Final Fantasy VI [SNES, GBA]
5.5: *Megaman X Command Mission [PS2]
5.5: Star Ocean Till The End Of Time [PS2]
5.5: Suikoden [PSX]
5.5: Wild ARMs [PSX]
5.4: Bahamut Lagoon [SNES]
5.4: *Blue Dragon [XBox 360]
5.3: Dragon Warrior VII [PSX]
5.2: Morrowind [PC]
5.2: Monster Rancher 4 [PS2]
5.2: *Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner [PS2]
5.2: Star Ocean: The Second Story [PSX]
5.1: Rogue [PC]
5.1: Chrono Trigger [SNES]
5.1: Fire Emblem 7 [GBA]
5.0: Elnard [SNES, jp, Japanese 7th Saga]
5.0: Pokemon Platinum [NDS]
5.0: Final Fantasy IX [PSX]

4.9: *Ogre Battle 64 [N64]
4.8: Odin Sphere [PS2]
4.7: Shadow Hearts [PS2]
4.7: Lufia 2 [SNES]
4.6: Monster Rancher Advance 1 [GBA]
4.5: *Shin Megami Tensei 1 [SNES]
4.5: *Shin Megami Tensei 2 [SNES]
4.5: Alundra [PSX]
4.4: Pokemon Emerald [GBA]
4.4: *Front Mission 4 [PS2]
4.3: Pokemon D/P [DS]
4.3: Dragon Warrior IV [NES]
4.3: *Paper Mario [N64]
4.2: Earthbound [SNES]
4.1: Arc the Lad [PSX]
4.1: *Wild ARMs 3 [PS2]
4.1: *Chrono Cross [PSX]
4.1: Soul Blazer [SNES]
4.1: Dragon Warrior Monsters 1 [GBC]
4.0: Digital Devil Saga 1 [PS2]
4.0: Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire [GBA]

Anything below here is either unreplayable (unless I'n stat-topicing it, for some bizarre reason) or have replay as their only redeeming aspect (SD3).

3.9: Seiken Denetsu 3 [SNES]
3.8: *Onimusha Tactics [GBA]
3.8 *Tales of Phantasia [GBA]
3.8: Final Fantasy VIII [PSX]
3.7: Legend of Legaia [PSX]
3.7: Terranigma [SNES]
3.6: *Fire Emblem 4 [SNES]
3.5: Tales of Eternia/Tales of Destiny 2 [PSX]
3.5: Diablo 2 [PC]
3.5: Super Mario RPG [SNES]
3.5: Pokemon Gold/Silver [GBC]
3.4: Oblivion [PC]
3.4: Final Fantasy VII [PSX]
3.3: Secret Of Mana [SNES]
3.3: Shadowrun [SNES]
3.2: *Riviera: The Promised Land [GBA]
3.1: *Revelations: Persona [PSX]
3.1: *Shadowrun [Genesis] (yes, these are two completely different games)
3.0: Breath Of Fire 2 [SNES, GBA]

2.9: *Final Fantasy [NES]
2.9: Dragon Warrior II [GBC]
2.7: Pokemon R/B/Y [GB]
2.6: Illusion of Gaia [SNES]
2.6: Threads of Fate [PSsomething]
2.6: Arcana [SNES]
2.5: *Grandia [PSX]
2.4: Ginormo Sword [INTERNET]
2.4: Shining Force II [Genesis]
2.3: *Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together [PSX]
2.2: *Final Fantasy II [NES, PSX]
2.2: Final Fantasy Legend [GB]
2.2: Final Fantasy MQ [SNES]
2.1: *Xenosaga Episode 1 [PS2]
2.1: *Jade Cocoon [PSX]
2.0: Final Fantasy XII [PS2]
2.0: Breath of Fire 1 [SNES]
2.0: Pokemon Stadium [N64]

1.9: *Kingdom Hearts [PS2]
1.9: Dragon Warrior I [GBC]
1.8: Breath of Fire III [PSX]
1.6: *Golden Sun 2 [GBA]
1.5: The 7th Saga [SNES]
1.5: Sword of Hope [GB]
1.4: *Lufia: The Legend Returns [GBC]
1.4: Shadow Hearts: From The New World [PS2]
1.3: *Phantasy Star [Genesis]
1.3: Magi Nation [GBC]
1.2: E.V.O: Search for Eden [SNES]
1.1: Golden Sun [GBA]
1.1: Diablo [PC]
1.0: Final Fantasy IV [SNES]

0.9: Suikoden IV [PS2]
0.8: *Shadow Madness [PSX]
0.7: Quest 64 [N64]
0.7: Legend of Dragoon [PSX]
0.6: *Magna Carta [PS2]
0.6: *Phantasy Star 3 [Genesis]
0.5: *Jade Cocoon 2 [PS2]
0.5: *Albert Odyssey [Saturn]
0.4: *Alundra 2 [PSX]
0.4: Tactics Ogre: Knight Of Lodis [GBA]
0.4: Final Fantasy Tactics Advance [GBA]
0.2: *Yggdra Union [GBA]
0.1: *Stella Deus [PS2]
0.1: Willow [NES]
0.1: Monster Rancher 3 [PS2]

[Meeplelard]

10/10 (Perfect, or so god damn close it doesn't matter)
Final Fantasy 6
Final Fantasy 10
Final Fantasy Tactics
Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance (aka FE9)
Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn (aka FE10)

9/10 (Stupidly good games that aren't quite perfect)
Breath of Fire 4
Breath of Fire 5
Phantasy Star 4
Pokemon Fire Red/Leaf Green
Shadow Hearts Convenant
Star Ocean: Til the End of Time
Valkyrie Profile
Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria
Wild ARMs 3
Wild ARMs 4

8/10 (Kick ass games, and nothing more)
Bahamut Lagoon (SNES)
Blue Dragon
Breath of Fire 3
Chrono Trigger
Crisis Core: Final Fantasy 7
Final Fantasy 3 (both versions)
Final Fantasy 7
Final Fantasy 9
Final Fantasy 13
Final Fantasy Tactics Advanced 2
Grandia 3
Kingdom Hearts 2
Lunar Eternal Blue Complete
Mega Man Starforce 3: Red Joker/Black Ace
Mega Man X Command Mission
Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald
Pokemon Heart Gold/Soul Silver
SaGa Frontier
Skies of Arcadia: Legends
Suikoden 3
Tales of Vesperia
Wild ARMs XF

7/10 (Good games, but not amazing)
Brigandine
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (DNR)
Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories
Dragon Quest 8
Earthbound
Final Fantasy 4 DS
Final Fantasy 5 (Advanced)
Final Fantasy 12
Fullmetal Alchemist and the Broken Angel
Fullmetal Alchemist 2: Curse of the Crimson Elixir
Front Mission 4
Kingdom Hearts
Kingdom Hearts 358/2 Days
Legaia 2: Duel Saga
Legend of Mana
Mana Khemia
Mega Man Starforce 2: ZerkerxNinjaxSaurian
Mega Man Starforce Dragon/Pegasus/Leo
Pokemon Diamond/Pearl
Pokemon Gold/Silver/Crystal
Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness
Seiken Densetsu 3 (SNES)
Star Ocean: 2nd Story
Star Ocean: The Last Hope
Suikoden Tactics
Suikoden 5
Tales of Eternia
Tales of Legendia
Tales of Phantasia
Tales of Symphonia
Tales of Symphonia 2: Dawn of the New World
Treasure Hunter G
Wild ARMs Alter Code F
Wild ARMs 2
Wild ARMs 5
Xenosaga 2: Jenseits von Gut und Bose

6/10 (Above Average, meaning they are good "filler" games...)
Arc the Lad: Twilight of Spirits
Anachronox
Barkley: Shut Up And Jam Gaiden: Hoopz Barkley Saga
Breath of Fire
Chaos Wars
Digital Devil Saga 2
Disgaea: Hour of Darkness
Dragon Quest 4
Dragon Quest 5
Final Fantasy 1: Soul of Chaos
Final Fantasy 2: Soul of Rebirth
Final Fantasy 4 (Advanced)
Fire Emblem 6: The Sword of Seals
Fire Emblem 7
Fire Emblem 8: The Sacred Stones
Golden Sun: The Lost Age
Grandia
Grandia 2
Legend of Dragoon
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
Naruto RPG: Uketsugareshi Hi no Ishi (GBA)
Ogre Battle
Phantom Brave
Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow
Radical Dreamers (SNES)
Rudra no Hihou (aka The Treasures of Rudra)
Secret of Evermore
Shadow Hearts
Shadow Hearts: From the New World
Suikoden
Suikoden 2
Suikoden 4
Tales of the Abyss
Tales of the World: Narikiri Dungeon 3 (GBA)
Xenosaga: Der Wille Zur Macht

5/10 (Average)
Arc the Lad 3
Breath of Fire 2
Chrono Cross
Final Fantasy Mystic Quest
Final Fantasy 1
Lufia 2
Mega Man Battle Network 2
Rhapsody (PSX)
Shining Force (Remake)
Shining Force 2
Super Mario RPG
Sword of Mana
Vandal Hearts

4/10 (Mediocre games)
Arc the Lad
Arc the Lad 2
Atelier Iris: Eternal Mana
Baldur's Gate
Final Fantasy 2
Final Fantasy 8
Final Fantasy Adventure (Gameboy)
Final Fantasy Legends/SaGa 3 (Gameboy)
Front Mission 3
Golden Sun
Inuyasha: The Secret of the Cursed Mask
Koudelka
Live a Live
Lufia 3: The Legend Returns
Lufia 4: Ruins of Lore
Mega Man Battle Network
Mega Man Battle Network 3 Blue/White
Okage: Shadow King
Persona 2: Eternal Punishment
Persona 4
Pokemon Colosseum
Radiata Stories
Ranma 1/2 RPG: The Treasure of the Red Cat Gang
Secret of Mana
Slayers (SNES)
Super Robot Wars 3
Tales of Destiny
The Legend of the Ghost Lion (NES)
Thousand Arms
Xenogears
Wild ARMs
Wizard of Oz: Beyond the Yellow Brick Road
Valkyrie Profile: Covenant of the Plume
Xenosaga 3: Also Spracht Zarathustra

3/10 (Bad games)
7th Saga
Beyond the Beyond
Digital Devil Saga
Dragon View
Dragon Warrior 3
Dragon Warrior 7
Final Fantasy Tactics Advanced
Final Fantasy X-2
Fire Emblem Gaiden (aka FE2)
Fire Emblem Geneology of the Holy War (aka FE4)
Fire Emblem Shadow Dragon
Front Mission
Kingdom Hearts: Chain of Memories
Legend of Legaia
Mother (aka Earthbound 0, NES)
Odin Sphere (DNR)
Phantasy Star 2
Robotrek
Revelations: Persona
Sailor Moon: Another Story
Secret of the Stars
Star Ocean
Tactics Ogre
Terranigma
Yu-gi-Oh: Forbidden Memories

2/10 (Games that just downright suck)
Dragon Crystal (Game Gear)
Dragon Quest
Dragon Quest 2
Dragon Quest 6
Final Fantasy Legends
Great Greed
Hoshigami: Ruining Blue Earth
Lufia 1
Paladin's Quest
Phantasy Star 3
Romancing Saga 3

1/10 (Outright Horrid)
Dragon Ball Z: Legend of the Super Saya-jin (SNES)
Dragon Ball Z: Attack of the Saya-jins (NES)
Dragon Ball Z 2: Lord Frieza's Fury (NES)
Dragon Ball Z 3: The Android Saga (NES) (Not the official name, but I know it was based off this Saga)
Dragon Ball Z Son Gokuden (SNES)
Dragon Ball Z Son Gokuden 2 (SNES)
Drakkhen
Lord of the Rings (SNES)
Quest 64
Super Robot Wars

0/10 (SUCK COMPRESSED INTO A GAME)
Ancient Domains of Mystery (aka ADOM)
Hydlide
Phantasy Star
Super Hydlide

[Linthar]

Here's the latest version of my list.

10/10:
1. Baldur's Gate 2
2. Shadow Hearts Covenant

9/10:
3. Paper Mario 2
4. Wild ARMs 4
5. Skies of Arcadia Legends
6. Disgaea
7. Geneforge 2

8/10:
8. Final Fantasy Tactics
9. Final Fantasy VI
10. Tales of Symphonia
11. Wild ARMs 3
12. Xenosaga
13. Baldur's Gate
14. Wild ARMs 2
15. Knights of the Old Republic (PC)
16. Exile 2: Crystal Souls (PC)
17. Exile 3: Ruined World (PC)
18. Geneforge 1 (PC)
19. Suikoden II
20. Suikoden III
21. Tales of The Abyss
22. Shadow Hearts
23. Fire Emblem Path of Radience

7/10:
24. Star Ocean: Till the End of Time*
25. Chrono Trigger
26. Xenosaga 2
27. Fire Emblem 7
28. Final Fantasy IX
29. Suikoden
30. Wild ARMs
31. Tales of Legendia*
32. Baten Kaitos*
33. Might and Magic 4/5: World of Xeen (PC)
34. Might and Magic 7 (PC)
35. Lunar Silver Star Story Complete

6/10:
36. Pokemon G/S/C
37. Xenogears*
38. Shining Force Neo *
39. Exile: Escape from the Pit
40. Tales of Phantasia (GBA)

5/10:
41. Arc The Lad 2
42. Final Fantasy Legend 3
43. Azure Dreams

4/10:
44. Arc The Lad 4*
45. Final Fantasy Tactics Advance*
46. Golden Sun*
47. Shining Force: Ressurection of the Dark Dragon*

3/10:
48. Final Fantasy X-2*
49. Breath of Fire 2
50. Arc The Lad
51. Arc The Lad 3*

2/10:


1/10:

* = not finished

For anyone interested a few games have been added since my last version on the previous board.
They are
Shadow Hearts 1 at 8/10
Shadow Hearts Covenant at 10/10 making it the second game I've ever given that rating
Lunar Silver Star Story Complete at 7/10
And Fire Emblem the Path of Radiance at 8/10.

[superaielman]

10/10

Final Fantasy Tactics
Final Fantasy 4
Dragon Warrior 4R
Star Ocean 2
Front Mission 4
Soul Nomad
Brigandine/Brigandine: Grand Edition
Ogre Battle: March of the Black Queen
SaGa Frontier

9/10

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (DNR)
Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow (DNR)
Suikoden 2
Final Fantasy 6
Valkyria Chronicals
Phantom Brave
Persona 4
Tales of the Abyss
Suikoden 3
Final Fantasy 7
Lufia 2

8/10

Grandia
Fire Emblem 10
Vandal Hearts 2
Wild Arms 4
Tales of Vesperia
Final Fantasy I
Valkyrie Profile 2
Dragon Quest 8
Mana Khemia
Suikoden 5
Grim Grimoire
Fire Emblem: 9
Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow (DNR)
Disgaea 2
Skies of Arcadia: Legends

7/10

Grandia 2
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance
Baldur's Gate: Shadows of Amn
Parasite Eve
Digital Devil Saga 2
Seiken Densetsu 3
Wild ARMs XF
Fire Emblem 8
Shadow Hearts
Shadow Hearts: Covenant

6/10


7th Saga
Xenogears
Breath of Fire 2
Breath of Fire 1
Suikoden
Fire Emblem 7
Phantasy Star 4
Kartia
Disgaea
Star Ocean 3
Pokemon Leafgreen
Pokemon Emerald
Dragon Quest 5
Chrono Trigger
Tactics Ogre: Knights of Lodis

5/10

Dragon Warrior 3
Tales of Destiny
Legaia: Duel Saga
Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter
Xenosaga: Jenseits von Gut und Bose
Vandal Hearts

4/10

Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirits
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
Digital Devil Saga 1
Baldur's Gate
Golden Sun
Final Fantasy 10
Final Fantasy 9
Lufia & the Fortress of Doom
Lunar: Eternal Blue Complete
Legend of Mana
Wild ARMs 3

3/10

Breath of Fire 4
Breath of Fire 3
Shining Force: Resurrection of the Dark Dragon
Wild ARMs 2
Lagoon
Shadow Hearts: From the New World
Radiata Stories
Xenosaga: Der Wille zur Macht
Suikoden 4
Stella Deus

2/10

Arc the Lad
Arc the Lad 2
Super Mario RPG
Grandia 3
Tactics Ogre: Let us Cling Together
Persona: Revelations
Valkyrie Profile
Valkyrie Profile: DS
Wild ARMs

1/10

Secret of Mana
Dragon Warrior
Legend of Dragoon
Tales of Eternia
Legend of Legaia
Chrono Cross
Secret of Evermore
Shining Force 2
Final Fantasy 8
Final Fantasy 5
Megaman X Command Mission

0/10

Dragon Warrior 7
Phantasy Star
Phantasy Star 2
Dragon Warrior 2
Phantasy Star 3
Xenosaga 3
The last remnant
Beyond the Beyond
Dragon Ball Z: Legend of the Super Sayjin
Hoshigami
Drakkhen
ADOM

[Hunter Sopko]

10/10
Shadow Hearts: Covenant
Wild Arms
Persona 4
Xenogears

9/10
Suikoden II
Phantasy Star IV
Wild Arms: Alter Code F
Kingdom Hearts
Lunar 2: Eternal Blue Complete
Wild Arms 2
Suikoden III
Breath of Fire IV
Thousand Arms
Star Ocean 3
.hack//G.U. Volume 1: Rebirth
Disgaea: Hour of Darkness
Generation of Chaos IV

8/10
Wild Arms 5
Wild Arms 4
Riviera
Kingdom Hearts 2
Final Fantasy Tactics
.hack//G.U. Volume 3: Redemption
Front Mission 3
Wild Arms XF
Mana Khemia
Grandia 2
Tales of the Abyss
Pokemon Sapphire
Dragon Quest 8
.hack//mutation
Ogre Battle PSX: March of the Black Queen
Final Fantasy VI

7/10  
Tales of Eternia
Valkyria Chronicles
.hack//infection
Valkyrie Profile
Suikoden V
Shadow Hearts
Wild Arms 3
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
Final Fantasy X
Final Fantasy VII
Breath of Fire III
Brigandine
Suikoden Tactics
Shining Force Resurrection

6/10
Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories
.hack//G.U. Volume 2: Reminisce
Grandia
.hack//Quarantine
Shadow Hearts: From the New World
Breath of Fire 5
Chaos Wars
Vandal Hearts
Pokemon Blue
Generation of Chaos: Aedis Eclipse
Xenosaga Episode 1
Chrono Trigger
La Pucelle

5/10
Tales of the World: Radiant Mythology
Persona 3 FES: The Journey
Persona 3 FES: The Answer
Atelier Iris: Eternal Mana
Suikoden IV
Cross Edge
Phantasy Star II
Legend of Legaia
Rhapsody: A Musical Adventure

4/10
Chrono Cross
Final Fantasy
Suikoden
Arc the Lad 4
Ergheiz Dungeon Mode

3/10
Ar Tonelico
.hack//outbreak
Fire Emblem 7
Phantasy Star III

2/10
Star Ocean 2
Final Fantasy Legend 2

1/10
Phantasy Star
Beyond the Beyond

[Dark Holy Elf]

10/10: The best of the best. These games are solid in almost all if not all categories, at times getting even into the exceptional.
1. Final Fantasy Tactics
2. Final Fantasy X
3. Wild ARMs 4
4. Suikoden 3
5. Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn (FE10)
6. Wild ARMs: XF

9/10: These games either just miss the cut on overall quality for a 10, or are a bit too unbalanced. They're extremely good too, but just not quite at the level of the best.
7. Final Fantasy 6
8. Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance (FE9)
9. Fire Emblem: Blazing Sword (FE7)
10. Wild ARMs 3
11. Valkyrie Profile
12. Chrono Trigger
13. Phantasy Star 4

8/10: Really good games. While not quite at the level of the above, these games are all incredible at what they set out to do.
14. Grandia 3
15. Xenogears
16. Pokemon Emerald
17. Mega Man X Command Mission
18. Breath of Fire 4
19. Suikoden 5
20. Xenosaga Episode II
21. Final Fantasy 7
22. Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones (FE8)

7/10: Clearly above average. They're good, but I don't feel passionately about their quality.
23. Shadow Hearts: From the New World
24. Mana Khemia 2: Fall of Alchemy
25. Star Ocean: Til the End of Time
26. Lunar 2: Eternal Blue Complete
27. Shadow Hearts: Covenant
28. Suikoden 2
29. Final Fantasy 5
30. Wild ARMs 5
31. Final Fantasy 3
32. Fire Emblem: The Sword of Seals (FE6)

6/10: Generically above average, the last group I tend to recommend.
33. Mana Khemia: Alchemists of Al-Revis
34. The Wizard of Oz
35. The Legend of Dragoon
36. Super Robot Wars Original Generation 2
37. Wild ARMs: Alter Code F
38. Pokemon Crystal(/Gold/Silver)
39. Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon
40. Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow
41. Super Robot Taisen OG Saga: Endless Frontier
42. Breath of Fire

5/10: Average, yet worthy of note. Decent games, but not as much to my taste as the above.
43. Legaia 2: Duel Saga
44. Pokemon Diamond(/Pearl)
45. The Legend of Mana
46. Dragon Quest 8
47. Super Mario RPG
48. Xenosaga Episode I
49. Super Robot Wars Original Generation 1
50. Grandia 2
51. Digital Devil Saga 2
52. Breath of Fire 2
53. Final Fantasy 9
54. Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
55. Breath of Fire 3
56. Brigandine

4/10: The flaws start compromising the game. Average but they have some issues.
57. Suikoden
58. Wild ARMs 2
59. Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria
60. Suikoden 4
61. Seiken Densetsu 3
62. Dragon Warrior 4
63. Digital Devil Saga
64. Final Fantasy 4
65. Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter
66. Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga

3/10: These games have issues. Not terrible, but...
67. Final Fantasy 8
68. Star Ocean: The Second Story
69. Shining Force 2
70. Shadow Hearts
71. Valkyrie Profile: Covenant of the Plume
72. Vandal Hearts
73. Chrono Cross
74. Final Fantasy

2/10: Ew. This is the beginning of the failure.
75. Tales of the Abyss
76. Grandia
77. Xenosaga Episode III
78. Disgaea: Hour of Darkness
79. Shining Force
80. Final Fantasy X-2*
81. Tales of Symphonia*
82. Wild ARMs

1/10: Wow, now there aren't even really any redeeming features.
83. Final Fantasy 2
84. Final Fantasy: Crystal Chronicles*
85. Secret of Mana
86. Lufia 2

0/10: You SUCK!
87. Lufia 1*

[Ciato]

10/10
1.   Final Fantasy Tactics
2.   Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn

9/10

3.   Brigandine: Legend of Forsena
4.   SaGa Frontier
5.   Wild Arms 4
6.   Shadow Hearts: Covenant
7.   Dragon Quest 8
8.   Suikoden II
9.   Breath of Fire III
10.   Ogre Battle: The March of the Black Queen
11.   Breath of Fire IV
12.   Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together

8/10

13.   Suikoden III
 14.   Final Fantasy X
15.   Suikoden V
16.   Persona 2: Eternal Punishment
17.   Phantasy Star IV
18.   Pokemon Leafgreen
19.   Chrono Trigger
20.   Valkyrie Profile
21.   Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones
22.   Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance
23.   Wild Arms XF
24.   Pokemon Emerald
25.   Star Ocean: Til the End of Time

7/10

26.   Final Fantasy V
27.   Grandia 3
28.   Pokemon HeartGold
29.   Live a Live
30.   Shining Force 2
31.   Digital Devil Saga 2
32.   Megaman X: Command Mission
33.   Kingdom Hearts
34.   Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
35.   Soul Nomad and the World Eaters
36.   Mana Khemia: The Alchemists of Al-Revis
37.   Super Mario RPG: The Legend of the Seven Stars

6/10

38.   Fire Emblem: The Blazing Sword
39.   Lunar: Eternal Blue Complete
40.   Xenosaga Episode II: Jenseits von Gut und Bose
41.   Final Fantasy III DS
42.   Final Fantasy IV
43.   Final Fantasy IX
44.   Digital Devil Saga
45.   Wild Arms 2
46.   Final Fantasy VIII
47.   Suikoden Tactics
48.   Vandal Hearts 2
49.   Shadow Hearts: From the New World

5/10

50.   Pokemon Diamond
51.   Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter
52.   Shadowrun
53.   Shadow Hearts
54.   Growlanser II: A Sense of Justice
55.   Suikoden
56.   Final Fantasy VI
57.   Tactics Ogre: The Knight of Lodis
58.   Shining Force: Resurrection of the Dark Dragon
59.   Shining Force Gaiden: Final Conflict
60.   Breath of Fire
61.   Fire Emblem: The Sword of Seals*
62.    Front Mission III*
63.   Grandia 2
64.   Paladin’s Quest*
65.   Disgaea: Hour of Darkness
66.   Arc the Lad: The Twilight of Spirits

4/10

67.   Great Greed
68.   Xenosaga Episode I: Der Wille Zur Macht
69.   Vandal Hearts
70.   Final Fantasy VII
71.   Chrono Cross*
72.   Star Ocean: The Second Story
73.   King’s Bounty
74.   Suikoden IV
75.   Wild Arms
76.   Final Fantasy X-2*

3/10

77.   Dragon Warrior IV*
78.   Final Fantasy I: Dawn of Souls
79.   Shining in the Darkness*
80.   Tales of the Abyss
81.   Lufia: The Rise of the Sinistrals
82.   Saga Frontier II*
83.   Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria
84.   Grandia*

2/10

85.   Final Fantasy Tactics: Advanced
86.   Wild Arms 3
87.    Xenogears
88.    Drakkhen*
89.   Phantasy Star I*
90.   Phantasy Star II*
91.   Thousand Arms*
92.   Xenosaga Episode III: Also Sprach Zarathustra

1/10

93.   Breath of Fire II*
94.   Seiken Densetsu 3

[Dhyerwolf]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
10/10
Shadow Hearts 2
Star Ocean 2
Star Ocean 3
Valkyrie Profile

9/10
Koudelka
Legend of Dragoon
Tales of Eternia
Wild Arms 4

8/10
Breath of Fire 5
Grandia 2
Final Fantasy IX
Final Fantasy Tactics
Shadow Hearts
Soul Nomad
Tales of the Abyss
Vagrant Story
Valkyrie Profile 2

7/10
Digital Devil Saga 2
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy X
Grandia 3
Mana Khemia
Odin Sphere
Persona 4
Radiata Stories
Shadow Hearts 3
Skies of Arcadia
Suikoden 5
Tales of Legendia
Valkyrie Profile: CotP
Wild Arms 3
Wild Arms 5
Wild Arms XF

6/10
Breath of Fire 2
Brigandine
Chrono Trigger
Ergheiz Dungeon Mode
Final Fantasy V
Final Fantasy VIII
Final Fantasy X-2
Grandia
Legend of Legaia
Legaia 2: Duel Saga
Persona 2
Star Ocean: First Departure
Suikoden 2
Suikoden Tiekreis
Tales of Destiny
Tales of Phantasia
Vandal Hearts
Wild Arms ACF
Wild Arms 2
Xenogears

5/10
Arc the Lad 4
Ar Tonelico
Breath of Fire IV
Digital Devil Saga 1
Dragon Quest 8
Chrono Cross
Final Fantasy IVa
Final Fantasy VI
Golden Sun
Lufia 3
Lunar EBC
Lunar SSC
Persona 3
Pokemon GSC
Pokemon RBY
PS 4
Saga Fronteir
Suikoden
Wild Arms
Xenosaga 3

4/10
Arc the Lad 2
Atelier Iris 1
Breath of Fire 3
Disgaea 2
FF 1: DoS
Final Fantasy IV
Final Fantasy Mystic Quest
Fire Emblem 7
Fire Emblem 8
Lufia
Mega Man X Command Mission
Persona
Pokemon RSE
Seiken Dentetsu 3
Suikoden 3
Suikoden Tactics
Tales of Symphonia
Xenosaga
Xenosaga 2

3/10
Arc the Lad: End of Darkness
Arc The Lad 3*
Baldur's Gate 2
Breath of Fire 1
Disgaea
DW IV
Earthbound
Eternal Poison 3
Fire Emblem 9
Lufia 2
Shining Force
Suikoden 4
Super Mario RPG

2/10
Baldur's Gate
Final Fantasy 3:DS
Jade Cocoon
Phantasy Star
Shining Force 2

1/10
Arc The Lad

0/10
Final Fantasy 12*
Phantasy Star 2
Ogre Battle
Secret of Mana (-10/10)

[metroid composite]

Just as forewarning, new forum will probably mean new spreadsheet on my part--in other words, lists from the old topic won't be tallied.  By all means copy and paste your old list, this just seems like a good opportunity to make sure the lists are up to date (not to mention shrink the spreadsheet to a slightly more manageable size).

[superaielman]

Oooh, that means it's time for Niu to post an updated list!

[NotMiki]

Is there going to be another list at the top linking to people's ratings?  I found that very helpful last time around.

[Dark Holy Elf]

... yeah, there should probably have been a first post at the top saved for things like an explanation of what the topic is for and those links. Though I suppose Tonfa's post could always be hijacked for that if he doesn't mind.

[Tonfa]

Edited into the first post. However, there's a small problem: Can't seem to figure out how to link to invidual posts if that's even possible. Those links redirect to the page the list is in though so not a huge deal, just a minor inconvenience. (Of course, all lists are at page 1 right now anyway...)

EDIT: Nevermind, think I figured it out. Changing links now.

NINJA EDIT: And done.

[Dark Holy Elf]

Awesome. Thanks, Tonfa.

[Strago]

Wooooo RPG Ratings. Heck yeah. An asterisk indicates a game I haven't finished but saw enough of to rank. A pound symbol indicates a game I haven't finished that I'm not really ranking educatedly but I don't care because I hate it.

10/10
Baldur's Gate II
Persona 2: Eternal Punishment
Planescape: Torment

9/10
Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obsura
Final Fantasy Tactics
Koudelka
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga 2
Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne
Suikoden II
Suikoden III
Suikoden V

8/10
Anachronox
Breath of Fire V: Dragon Quarter
Earthbound
Fallout
Fallout 2
Final Fantasy VI
Final Fantasy X
Lunar: Eternal Blue Complete
Paper Mario
Shadow Hearts: Covenant
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga
Skies of Arcadia: Legends
Wild Arms: Advanced 3rd
Wild Arms: 4th Detonator
Xenogears
Xenosaga Episode II: Jenseits von Gut und Bose

7/10
Baldur's Gate
Breath of Fire IV
Disgaea: Hour of Darkness
Dragon Quest VIII
Front Mission 4
Grandia II
Lord of the Rings: The Third Age
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
Icewind Dale II*
Persona: Revelations
Star Ocean: Til the End of Time
Suikoden
Suikoden Tactics
Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars
Vagrant Story
Valkyrie Profile
Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria
Wild Arms: Alter Code F
Wild Arms: 2nd Ignition
Xenosaga Episode I: Der Wille Zur Macht

6/10
Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirits
Chrono Cross
Chrono Trigger
Final Fantasy IV Advance
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy IX
Fire Emblem 7
Fire Emblem 8
Grandia
Icewind Dale
Kingdom Hearts*
Legend of Mana
Neverwinter Nights
Shadow Hearts*
Tales of Symphonia
Wild Arms

5/10
Dragon Warrior IV*
Final Fantasy IV
Final Fantasy V*
Illusion of Gaia*
Legend of Dragoon*
Lufia 2
Ogre Battle: March of the Black Queen*
Parasite Eve
Pokemon R/B/Y
Star Ocean: The Second Story
Suikoden IV
Tales of Phantasia*

4/10
Breath of Fire II#
Breath of Fire III
Final Fantasy VIII
Secret of Evermore#
Shining Force II#

3/10
Phantasy Star IV
SaGa Frontier

[Lady Ashe]

10/10

Final Fantasy X
Shadow Hearts: Covenant
Wild ARMs 4
The World Ends With You

9/10

Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
Shadow Hearts: From the New World
Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin
Diablo II: Lord of Destruction
Ogre Battle 64: Person of Lordly Caliber
Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3
Tales of the Abyss

8/10

Dragon Quest Monsters: Joker
Mega Man Battle Network 2
Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
Kingdom Hearts 2
Shadow Hearts
Final Fantasy VIII
Fire Emblem 7

7/10

Luminous Arc
Atelier Iris 2: The Azoth of Destiny
Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories
Etrian Odyssey
Kingdom Hearts: Chain of Memories
Final Fantasy X-2
Wild ARMs 3
Mana Khemia: Alchemists of Al-Revis
Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow
Mega Man Star Force: Dragon
Kingdom Hearts

6/10

Kingdom of Loathing
Fire Emblem 8
Final Fantasy VII
Pokemon Silver
Mega Man Battle Network

5/10

Utawarerumono
Dark Cloud
Xenosaga Episode I: Der Wille zur Macht
Suikoden IV

4/10

Castlevania: Harmony of Dissonance
Summon Night: Swordcraft Story

3/10

Pokemon Blue
Dragon Warrior

2/10

Golden Sun

1/10

Final Fantasy XII

[Meeplelard]

Added FE10 at 10/10.  FE9+ pretty much sums the game up, though in this case its more "Firmly 10/10" vs. "Borderline 10/10" <_<

Added DDS2 at 6/10.  Ranted about it, considerable step up vs. DDS1, etc.

[Taitoro]

Monster Rancher Advance 1 added at 4.6.
Shadow Hearts: Covenant, Valkyrie Profile and Suikoden III down 0.1 to 7.1.
Mordor 1.1: The Depths of Dejenol added at 7.2.
Rogue added at 5.1.
Nethack added at 5.8.
Angband added at 6.4.

None of the dungeon crawls are starred because playing to beat them bores me. >_> Gotten pretty far in all three, though, and enjoy dinkin' around in 'em.